Review : February Flowers

February Flowers by Fan Wu
Pages : 300
Genre : Fiction, China, GLBT
Stand alone
My Rating :

What it’s about :

It is the fall of 1991, in China, when seventeen years old Ming starts university. There she meets Yan, an older girl with a personality completely opposite to hers. As quiet  and innocent and idealistic as Ming is, Yan is outspoken and loud, and doesn’t care much about conventions. Yet despite their differences, the girls form a surprising friendship, forever changing Ming’s life.

My Thoughts :

February Flowers was everything I love about Chinese contemporary fiction – or at least, what I have personally experienced of it. It had a quiet pace, a beautiful narration and complex characters. Though the book is about Ming and Yan’s friendship, this is mainly the story of Ming and how that relationship changed her.

I guess it could be argued whether February Flowers is, or isn’t, about homosexuality. In fact, I have read reviews arguing both sides of this. The girls never truly engage in a sexual relationship, nor do they ever clearly say that they are homosexual or bisexual. They certainly flirt with the possibility, and Ming is clearly confused; she has a hard time determining whether her feelings for Yan are more than friendship, and if these feelings are precisely linked to Yan or to women in general. There is no clear answer given, either, and I liked that : no answer means no label, and I felt it was realistic that Ming wouldn’t be one thing or the other. It might be that she is somewhere in between, or that what she lived was specific to the situation with Yan and never to be reproduced. So while it might not be a GLBT novel in itself, the theme, from my point of view, is at least present.

I do think the book is a coming-of-age story : it’s about Ming finding who she is in this modern China, having the views she grew up with clashing with the world Yan is offering her. This story of discovery is a slowly paced one, and nothing much happens in term of events, but I loved getting to know Ming and see her relationship with Yan develop.

Yan isn’t a really likable character : fascinating and colorful, yes, but also manipulative and self-centered. But she also lived through some difficult things, so one might explain the other. I think her interest in quiet, studious, caring Ming, comes from a place of envy, or maybe curiosity, to know what her life could have been if she had made different choices or lived through different things.

I definitely enjoyed this study of characters, and a book set in modern China was a refreshing change of setting. The fact that Fan Wu did grow up in China and studied there, like Ming, only added to how realistic the setting felt.

Tags: , , ,

7 responses to “Review : February Flowers”

  1. BermudaOnion says :

    This sounds really good an relevant.

  2. Jennifer says :

    I like the fact that this book defies labels. Figuring out your sexuality is hard enough without trying to fit into the mold of a label. Sometimes two people just connect. Anyhoo, great review. I think you captured what was really good about this book. And it is one I think I might actually end up picking up.

    • kay says :

      “Sometimes two people just connect.” Exactly, and that’s what I liked in that book. Sometimes relationships are really difficult to “label”, and I find the more important they are, the more difficult it is.

  3. Amanda says :

    This sounds really fascinating and reminds me of If You Follow Me which I read earlier this year. I just ordered it off Paperback Swap. Thanks!

    • kay says :

      I haven’t read If You Follow Me yet (it’s on my TBR pile), but I remember your review, and it does remind me a little of it. I’ll be curious to hear what you think!

  4. mee says :

    I have read one or two good reviews on this book so I’ll keep an eye on it! The subject seems to be unique too, unlike some of the more common topics for many contemporary Chinese literature.

  5. Ceri says :

    Really like the sound of this, it sounds very interesting though. I do love books set in China – my mum always fills the house with contemporary or old fiction set in China for some reason so maybe this one will find its way into my hands. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: